A Puzzle - GTAP

A Puzzle - GTAP

Implications of a Free Trade Region (FTR) FTR China, REAS, India, ROSA, USA, EU Scenario: remove 100 percent of tariffs (TMS) and output subsidies (TO) on 19 Agricultural and Food Commodities Welfare Impacts China REAS India ROSA USA EU ROW 1,237 19,253 26

354 6,563 411 -2,529 Selim Raihan, Bangladesh 1 Removal of Tariffs in the Free Trade Region (FTR) Simulation Removal of Tariffs in the Region Simulated alternative Tariff Reductions Tariff reductions set at 30%, 50%, 70% and 100% of existing TMS Rate Conclusion: All countries that joined the Free Trade Region had positive welfare impacts for all reductions except one India. Paul J. Thomassin, McGill Univer sity Welfare Effects

25000 D o lla rs 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 1 2 3 4 -5000 China USA Percent Reduction REAS India EUR Paul J. Thomassin, McGill Univer

sity ROW ROSA Welfare Decomposition India 30 % 50 % 70% 100 % Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction 127.99 EV TOT 7.73 123.78 AE 187.85 209.23 -56.143 6.25 0.86

-16.71 187.13 215.52 -33.012 30% 50% 70% 100% Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction MTAX 160.49 156.32 156.33 Paul J. Thomassin, McGill Univer sity -147.89 Why? The reason for the decrease in allocation

efficiency from MTAX is from trade diversion. The main commodity causing this is Vegetable Oils and Fats (VOL) from Indonesia and Malaysia Paul J. Thomassin, McGill Univer sity Withdrawal of output subsidies in agriculture in SIX regions Page 1 I look at the welfare change 3 countries (IND, USA and EUR) are gaining 3 countries (CHN, REAS and ROSA) are loosing I concentrate on why REAS is loosing Welfare decomposition figures suggest that welfare loss in REAS is caused by loss in allocative efficiency and loss in terms of trade. I further concentrate on the loss in allocative efficiency The Puzzle Why there is a loss in allocative efficiency in REAS even though output subsidies on agriculture have been withdrawn. Selim Raihan, Bangladesh

6 Withdrawal of output subsidies in agriculture in SIX regions Page 2 You can have a decrease in allocative efficiency after a removal of output subsidies if after liberalization there is an expansion in the sectors who were previously receiving output subsidies. Therefore, we should check qo (industry output of commodity i in region r) 4 sectors were receiving output subsidies in agriculture in REAS: Paddy rice (PDR), Oil seeds (OSD), Live animals (CLT), and Raw milk (RMK). Simulation results suggest contraction of output in OSD, CTL and RMK (which are as expected). BUT, interestingly, output of Paddy Rice increases. Decomposing qo suggest that the increase in output in Paddy rice is primarily driven by the increase in exports of PDR from REAS. The share of exports of PDR from REAS in total PDR output in REAS is more than 88%. Selim Raihan, Bangladesh 7 Withdrawal of output subsidies in agriculture in SIX regions Page 3

Why do Exports of PDR from REAS increase? REAS and USA are the two major players in the international PDR export market, having 49% and 13% share in global PDR exports (VXWD). Base data on output subsidies suggest that USA has the highest rate of to on PDR (86%), whereas REAS has only 2%. Therefore, the withdrawal of output subsidies on PDR in USA make USA PDR expensive both at domestic and international market. This can be explained by the fact that PMS (PDR, USA, REAS) increases by 64%, while PMS(PDR, REAS,REAS) increases by only 2%. Production of PDR in USA declines by 55%. Therefore, exports of PDR from USA to REAS decreases and exports of PDR from REAS to both USA and REAS increase. The changes in volume of exports confirm that the increase in intra-regional trade of PDR in REAS is the principal contributor of the increase in exports. Finally, a decomposition of the allocative efficiency also suggest that there is a loss in import tariff revenue, because of the fall in imports in RESA since composite import price (pim) increase. Selim Raihan, Bangladesh 8

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Linear Theory of Ionization Cooling in 6D Kwang-Je

    Linear Theory of Ionization Cooling in 6D Kwang-Je

    Times New Roman Helvetica Eras Demi ITC Arial Symbol Wingdings Default Design Microsoft Word Picture Microsoft Equation 3.0 Microsoft Draw 98 Drawing Adobe Photoshop Image Linear Theory of Ionization Cooling in 6D PowerPoint Presentation Ionization Cooling Theory in Linear Approximation...
  • The Transition from the Classical period to the Hellenistic ...

    The Transition from the Classical period to the Hellenistic ...

    This transition between the classical and Hellenistic period caused the narratives told through the artwork to express scenes that depicted action and that dealt with pain and suffering. The classical period of course had events that dealt with this, but...
  • Text

    Text

    Repatriation and digital repatriation. Access and restriction of access. Actions. Engaging with this paper and session. ... He mihi nunui, engari he mihi poto ki a koutou . mō tō koutou āro me tō koutou tautoko . i tenei rā....
  • Lets Go 1 Unit 1 Lesson Plan 4

    Lets Go 1 Unit 1 Lesson Plan 4

    a book. Activity Review: Vocabulary . Lesson Objectives: The students will be able to learn new vocabulary and use them to construct sentences. Instructions: There's an animation in the ppt. Conduct a drill of the pictures with words. Do not...
  • Daily Living Skills and Mentoring Program

    Daily Living Skills and Mentoring Program

    Daily Living Skills andMentoring Program. Timesheet and Expense Sheet. ... Fancy fonts are not acceptable. Scanned, cut, and pasted signatures are not acceptable. NORTHWEST COUNSELING AND GUIDANCE CLINIC. TIMESHEET. CHIPPEWA DAILY LIVING SKILLS AND MENTORING PROGRAM. Chris Smith.
  • Presentation title goes here

    Presentation title goes here

    Welcome to All CFAS Attendees! More than 130 people are attending this meeting, including an array of CFAS reps, speakers, AAMC staff, and guests Of CFAS reps, approximately 55 percent are senior reps, and 45 percent are junior reps.
  • Exercise Physiology - The Basics

    Exercise Physiology - The Basics

    ATP-CP System. Replenishes ATP rapidly by breaking down Creatine Phosphate releasing energy to reform ATP. Short duration (<10 secs) Active at the beginning of all forms of activities . Especially important in high intensity exercises like weight lifting that require...
  • Chapter 10, section 1 - Home - Buckeye Valley

    Chapter 10, section 1 - Home - Buckeye Valley

    Chapter 10, section 1. Heredity manifests itself primary in the process called MATURATION. Maturation is developmental changes that occur as a result of automatic and sequential process of developmental that results from genetic signals. Critical Period - best time to...