Discussion points - RBF Health

Discussion points - RBF Health

DISCUSSION POINTS COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF RESULTS-BASED FINANCING PROGRAMS IN ZIMBABWE AND ZAMBIA, HRITF BBL, NOVEMBER 3, 2016 Edit Velenyi, PhD, Sr. Economist STATE OF CEA IN PBF IN HEALTH? A GLASS . MOH MOF Half Full 1st Applied CEA Toolkit 2 Empirical Studies in HRITF Portfolio Promising ICER results Precedent to avalanche? Trust Tools Implementation research to inform design and management.

Half Empty DPs Sea of Effectiveness vs. Islands of CEA Back of the envelope CEA Focusing on things that are easier (less controversial) to measure and easier to publish. IEG asked Why (ROSES, 2016)? Risk Aversion: Political Risks Evaluation Skills (CEA Experts) Operational Challenges Data Sources Audit Sensitivity of CEA Conclusions: It depends Approach Financial vs Economic Costs Implementer vs Societal Costs Fixed Costs vs Recurrent Short Term vs Long Run (Mature) EVIDENCE ON COST EFFECTIVENESS IN PBF IN HEALTH: LESSONS FROM EARLY ADOPTERS: FINDINGS & FRONTIERS Zimbabwe ICER: Highly cost-effective

Coverage: $663 or < $980 GDP/capita (2012) C + Quality: $439 < $980 GDP/capita (2012) Start-up vs. Mature Project Costs Assumptions (e.g. attrition, risk-based verification) Tanzania PBF example (Borghi et al., 2014) Cost: FC = $1.2 million EC = $2.3 million IC/Additional Facility Based Birth PILOT = $540-$907 IC/Additional Facility Based Birth NATIONAL = $94-$261 Impact

Variations in Costs, Cost Drivers SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS Variations in Lives Saved (2014) Comparison & Learning Cordaid & Crown Agents Sustainability Evaluations impact on GOZ Policy and Donors Zambia ICER: Highly cost-effective RBF vs INP: $1,350 < $1,759 GDP/capita RBF vs CON: $874 < $1,759 GDP/capita INP vs CON: $507 < $1,759 GDP/capita RBF vs INP No clear dominance Coverage Impact: RBP < INP for 2 highest incentivized targets (Ins Del, PNC)

Quality Impact: ? Issue: Complexity of Target (FP vs ID) Counterfactuals / D-Side Complements Vouchers CCT Health Insurance PUSHING THE CEA FRONTIERS 1.HRITF Portfolio Level Effectiveness: Generations of effectiveness studies and ambition for meta analysis (despite heterogeneity) CEA: What is the ambition? What are the lessons from the early adapters in operationalizing / implementing CEA? Can Clients/Task Teams draw on data New countries to scale collection tools and how-to tips to jump start CEAs? the experience? Willingness to test alternative CEA methods? 2.Client Perspective Is there support to use existing data or collect additional data for CEA? Are findings from CEAs used to inform program adjustments, scale up, and allocation decisions? PUSHING THE CEA

FRONTIERS 3. Broader Development Context For example, DFID V4M (2011) SDGs UHC V4M MFM V4M does not mean we only do the cheapest things, but we do have to get better at understanding our costs. We do not just do the easiest things, but the agenda does mean we have to get better at measuring. Countries play a critical role in delivering results. We care about the results achieved with all development resources, not just our own. Despite the increased importance of V4M, there is little evidence on CEA in PBF. USE CEA TO INFORM CHOICES & INCREASE IMPACT K/D Ratio Cost/Lives Saved

Recently Viewed Presentations



    Example: Apple from a . tree. becomes food for . you. INPUTS & OUTPUTS. Sometimes the output from one system can become the input for another system. INPUTS & OUTPUTS. Can you label the inputs and outputs of the tea...
  • Head, Neck &amp; Face Skeletal Processes - MRS. ROGERS&#x27; ANATOMY

    Head, Neck & Face Skeletal Processes - MRS. ROGERS' ANATOMY

    5 Head, Neck and Face Chapter 5 - Head, Neck and Face Blank Slide Trail Guide Chapter 5 - Head, Neck & Face • Topographical View - pg. 119 • Bones and Bony Landmark - pg. 120 • Skull #1...
  • Mrs. Smiths Kindergarten Classroom Handbook Room 118 2015-2016

    Mrs. Smiths Kindergarten Classroom Handbook Room 118 2015-2016

    way to reach me is by email: [email protected] I check my email before and after school daily, so you can always count on a very prompt reply. Please feel free to send notes in with your child. The best place...
  • St. Joseph&#x27;s College S5 English Courses

    St. Joseph's College S5 English Courses

    Talking: skills in talking may be assessed by solo talk, group talk or class debate, as selected by the class teacher. What if my son/daughter fails a Unit Assessment? Generally only one resit is allowed, unless there are special circumstances.
  • Conflict Essay Review and Revision Tips

    Conflict Essay Review and Revision Tips

    Atticus' views contrast with the close-minded nature of the community, foreshadowing the uphill battle he will face against Maycomb'svalues LINKS TO QS- Theme, Character, Key Incident, Conflict
  • Oracle R12 Implementation Kick-Off Meeting

    Oracle R12 Implementation Kick-Off Meeting

    FINDINI 4.0.9 Release Summary. Objective: This release will be focused on integrating the new Concur Travel and Entertainment Expense system with the Oracle GL & PeopleSoft, upgrading the CPATH application to a more current version, upgrading the OBI Replication database...


    - ANG May supplement this document with a ANG Manual or ANGSUP. State Air Surgeon's role ... New Justification Process began Mid-January and pushed to the field via Heads-up in February; afterwhich, a steep decline in event requests occurred. ......
  • Kadrovski resursi i plae LUG, Mljet, 13.6.2016. Sadraj

    Kadrovski resursi i plae LUG, Mljet, 13.6.2016. Sadraj

    Model 69 PNB: 40002-OIB-P3. Zbog podrške novog SEPA(single europaymentsarea) formata za datoteku isplate obračuna bilo je potrebno podržati model 69 kojim se definira da poziv na broj može imati dva ili tri dijela. Prvi je dio fiksni 40002, zatim OIB...