Impact of Quality Matters Professional Development on Course ...
Impact of Quality Matters Professional Development on Course Design and Student Evaluations Dr. Sheri Conklin; Erika Hanson, Ginu Easow & Zach Morgan
Quick Check! At UNCW UNCW APPQMR
Course Design Research Question(s) Research Questions 1) Does QM professional development have
an impact on course design? 2) What types of changes are made as a result of developing expertise with the QM approach? 3) How does course design impact student evaluations?
Research Design Participants 65 potential participants 15 peer review
6 viable participant 3 final participants Exploratory Case Study Application of QM workshop to course design Course design
1 2 3
Data Collection Content Analysis Quick Check!
Quality Matters Clusters Eight QM Clusters 1. Clarity of Purpose 2. Ease of Use 3. Course Alignment
4. Learner Engagement 5. Accessibility Standards 6. Knowledge Acquisition 7. Compliance 8. Learner Support Legon, R. (2015). Measuring the impact of the Quality Matters Rubric: A discussion of possibilities. American Journal of Distance Education, 29(3), 166-173.
Quality Matters Clusters Learner Support QM Specific Standards 1.8 Self-introduction 1.9 Learner introduction
3.5 Opportunity to track progress 5.2 Active learning 6.2 Tools promote engagement 6.3 Variety of technology Cluster Index
Cluster Index=Initial Cluster Score Cluster Score Post Revision Data Collection
QM Clusters and Student Evaluations Learner Support Student Evaluation Crosswalk Alignment Student Evaluation Crosswalk
Q1 Found ways to help students answer questions Q9 Encouraged use of multiple resources Q20 Encouraged student-instructor interaction
Q6 Made it clear how each topic fit into the course Q10 Explained course material clearly and concisely
Limitations Limitations Exploratory case study Small sample Variation in student evaluation response rate
Natural disaster Update from 5th to 6th edition of QM rubric Student evaluation classification to QM clusters What We Found?
Course One Findings Spring 2015 Spring 2016
Spring 2017 . . . gives you a little more clarity, understanding how the course looks from the student point of view and tweaking it to make it clearer. My goal is to get almost no emails about little confused things, confusing about the assignment . . .
Course One Findings Course One Findings Course One Findings
2015 - I feel that this course is definitely in need of some streamlining. The assignments were listed in an illogical, unnecessarily complicated way. 2017 -[Professor] has done an excellent job designing this course. . . Course Two Findings
Spring 2017 Spring 2018 Fall 2018
. . . I made some changes that I can make quickly before a ... you know, I don't particularly like to make huge changes right before a semester. But if I have time, I'll change what I can. I typically, when I redo bigger courses, or need to do a larger overhaul, I'll do it during the summer. Course Two Findings
Course Two Findings Course Two Findings Spring 2017 - I appreciate the clarity and the depth with which he
teaches Spring 2018 - . . . always responding to emails and questions in a timely manner. Course Three Findings
Spring 2017 Fall 2017 Fall 2018
It's just forced me, I think, to really think of ways to meet those requirements, those kind of transparent things, but also not make it too, frankly, off-putting. In doing that, I think it's forced me to reexamine what I teach and how I teach because I've been doing it for a really, really, really long time, so in that sense, it was nice to get a refresh. . . . Course Three Findings
Course Three Findings Course Three Findings Spring 2017 - Communicates well and responds to emails quickly.
Fall 2018 - . . . was very organized and helpful throughout the course. Conclusions Research Question 1
Does QM professional development workshops have an impact on course design? Research Question 2 What types of changes are made as a result of developing expertise with the QM approach?
Ease of Use, Learner Engagement, and Learner Support Minimal changes to Knowledge Acquisition Research Question 3 How does course design impact student evaluations? QM revisions not directly linked to student evaluations
No patterns among courses with student evaluations Qualitative data from Student Evaluations referenced instructor social presence Quick Check!
Next Steps Next Steps Expand current study Application of QM workshop to course design Course design
75 potential faculty Next Steps Incorporate Community of Inquiry (CoI) into research study
Cognitive Presence Social Presence Teaching Presence
Next Steps QM Research aligning with student outcomes Questions Brinkley-Etzkorn, K. E. (2018). Learning to teach online: Measuring the influence of faculty development
training on teaching effectiveness through a TPACK lens. The Internet in Higher Education, 38, 28-35. Chen, K., Lowenthal, P. R., Bauer, C., Heaps, A., & Nielson, C. (2017). Moving beyond smile sheets: A case study on the evaluation and iterative improvement of an online faculty development program. Online Learning, 21(1), 85-111. Kearns, L., & Mancilla, R. (2017). The impact of Quality Matters professional development on teaching across delivery formats. American Journal of Distance Education, 31(3), 185-197.
Legon, R. (2015). Measuring the impact of the Quality Matters Rubric: A discussion of possibilities. American Journal of Distance Education, 29(3), 166-173. Roehrs, C., Wang, L., & Kendrick, D. (2013). Preparing faculty to use the Quality Matters model for course improvement. Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 9(1), 52-67. Shattuck, J., Dubins, B., & Zilberman, D. (2011). MarylandOnlines interinstitutional project to train higher education adjunct faculty to teach online. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,
12(2), 40-61. Yang, D. (2017). Instructional strategies and course design for teaching statistics online: Perspectives from online students. International Journal of STEM Education, 4(34), 1-15.
Ker je Danijel kralju razložil skrivnostne sanje, ga je hotel nagraditi z visoko službo v kraljestvu. Vendar se je Danijel kakršnemu koli odlikovanju odpovedal. Bog je torej Danijelu dal izreden dar preroških videnj, kar najdemo zapisano v stari zavezi (v...
Majority of protein coding variation is evolutionary recent, rare, and probably deleterious . Rare variants are contributing to human phenotypic variation and disease susceptibility, but it is not known how. It is not clear which is the medical implication of...
Tricare Health System. U.S. Naval Observatory. and others. Department of Defense research. Developed by: U-MIC 32 CFR 219. Department of Defense research. Developed by: U-MIC funding. cooperation, collaboration, or other agreements. ... University of Michigan Medical School ...
Next I have written a sample spec. Start by stating what it is you would like to purchase. Note I didn't just say apples but stated Red Delicious. Since this is the type I purchase most often. I made sure...
Animal music cognition. Simple motor entrainment is shared by humans with at least parrots and pinnipeds. But (apparently) not with other mammal species, e.g. dogs, cats. Maturational feature in humans > 2 years. Massive social influence is also an important...
Observer Pattern. According to the GoF book, the Observer design pattern should "Define a one-to-many dependency between objects so that when one object changes state, all its dependents are notified and updated automatically" A subject may have any number of...
After 10 days, this modifies the fat content in the egg yolk to contain more omega-3 fatty acids and less saturated and omega-6's In 1997, this was the Canadian New Product of the year Omega-3 Chickens Omega-3 meats Present work...