Improving Reading Outcomes for Students with or at Risk for ...

Improving Reading Outcomes for Students with or at Risk for ...

Connecting Research, Policy and Practice Improving Reading Outcomes for Students with or at Risk for Reading Disabilities: A Synthesis of the Contributions from the Institute of Education Sciences Research Centers Carol McDonald Connor, ASU Rollanda OConnor, UC-Riverside Intro - Joan McLaughlin, IES Q&As Elizabeth Albro, IES Available on IES Website 20143000.pdf 2 Acknowledgements Co-Authors Carol Connor (Chair), Arizona State Paul Alberto, Georgia State Donald Compton, Vanderbilt Rollanda OConnor, U of California, Riverside

3 Purpose of the Synthesis To review and synthesize articles and chapters that described products of IES funded research projects that focused on improving reading for children with or at risk for reading disabilities. Focus was on grants that were initially awarded from 2002 through 2008 through the National Center for Education Research and the National Center for Special Education Research.

4 Preparing the Synthesis IES identifies a topic for study, names a Chair, and with the Chairs input identifies a set of co-authors IES identifies all relevant grants for the topic articles & gathers all peer-reviewed articles and book chapters relevant to the topic For this synthesis, 48 research projects & 111 publications were reviewed Panel meets to discuss articles & frame the synthesis Synthesis is limited to IES-funded research Final product reflects panels expert judgment & is externally peer-reviewed prior to publication 5 Areas of Focus Assessment Basic Cognitive and Linguistic Processes Intervention Professional Development 6 Assessment What have we learned about effective identification and assessment of students who have or are at risk for reading difficulties or disabilities? 4 contributions 7

Contribution 1 Contribution 1. Screening all students reading skills (i.e., universal screening) at the beginning of the school year, especially in the early grades, can be a valid and efficient way to identify students who are at risk for poor reading outcomes. 8 Contribution 2 Contribution 2. Using assessments to monitor students progress can be a valid and efficient

way to guide the decision making process for example, through a Response to Intervention (RTI) approach-for determining whether an intervention is improving a student's reading skills. 9 Contribution 3 Contribution 3: New assessments for English learners indicate that reading comprehension can be assessed without overburdening word reading and oral language skills. 10 Contribution 4 Contribution 4: Assessment accommodations can be made for students with disabilities that do not modify the construct being measured, and therefore represent a valid measure of this construct. For example, reading aloud the Gates MacGinitie improved scores for students with LD but not for typical students (Cook et al., 2010) 11 And Since the Synthesis Was Published Early response to intervention measures Beach & OConnor, 2013 New ways of assessing reading for understanding OReilly et al., 2014 12

Basic Cognitive and Linguistic Processes What are the basic cognitive and linguistic processes that support successful reading and how can these skills be improved for students who have or who are at risk for reading disabilities? 3 Contributions 13 Contribution 5 Contribution 5: Several basic cognitive processes, including working

memory and abstract and inferential reasoning, have been found to be important for students reading success. For example, Glenberg et al., showed that enacting stories improved students retention of the stories. Swanson & OConnor (2009) conjectured that improving fluency might help compensate for weaker working memory. The intervention improved fluency but not working memory fluency and working memory operated independently. Van den Broek et al., 2009, used eye tracking to examine the reading skills of students. They found that although patterns of reading were similar (e.g., fixations) the weaker readers were less efficient and less strategic i.e., generating less coherent mental representations of the text

14 Contribution 6 Contribution 6. Malleable linguistic processes, such as oral language skills and vocabulary, contribute to childrens reading performance. Uccelli & Paez (2007): Spanish-English narrative skills and vocabulary Terry et al., (2012): changing use of nonmainstream dialect from first to second grade predicted reading outcomes 15

Contribution 7 Contribution 7: Although the same sets of cognitive and linguistic skills are involved in learning to read, children bring unique constellations of these skills to the classroom with important implications for instruction. 16 And Since the Synthesis Was Published Eye movement studies have illuminated processes of reading for understanding

Connor, Radach, et al., 2014 Vortius et al., 2013 Importance of metacognition for reading for understanding Roberts et al., 2014 17 Intervention How do we make reading instruction more effective for students who have or are at risk for developing reading disabilities? How do we

teach reading to students with low-incidence disabilities? 6 Contributions 18 Contribution 8: Increasing the intensity of interventions in kindergarten and first grade may prevent reading difficulties for many students. Kindergarten

Vadasy & Sanders, 2008, 2010: Effective also for ELL Hagan-Burke et al., 2010: Effective also for students with behavior difficulties Grade 1 Denton et al., 2010: Scales up effective intervention Reading rate continues to lag, on average

19 Contribution 9: Fluency interventions that focus on repeated reading or reading a range of text, along with opportunities to practice reading in the classroom may generally improve students fluency and comprehension. Vadasy & Sanders, 2008a,b: Gr 4-5 Vadasy & Sanders, 2009: Gr 2-3 OConnor et al., 2007, 2009, 2010: Gr 2 & 4 20 Contribution 10: Language outcomes for many children at risk for language disabilities can improve if they are provided extensive opportunities to hear and use complex oral language. K: Interactive discussion and practice of word meanings Coyne, McCoach, & Kapp, 2007 Loftus, Coyne et al., 2010 Gr 1: Teacher plus small group in a tiered model Maynard, Pullen & Coyne, 2010

Pullen et al., 2010 Forgetting was common for low-skilled students 21 Contribution 11: Peer-assisted or collaborative learning is a promising method of increasing the intensity of instruction for students and improving their reading outcomes. PALS McMaster, Fuchs, & Fuchs, 2008: Effective for many; however less effective than adult tutoring

Saenz et al., 2007: Include ELL Collaborative Strategic Reading Vaughn, Klingner et al., 2011: Grades 7-8 22 Contribution 12: Interventions that are differentiated to target an individual students profile of component skills can improve reading development. Connor et al., 2007, 2009, 2010, 2011: Gr K, 1, 3 Individualized Student Instruction, with Assessment to

Instruction guidance for teachers Gelzheiser et al., 2011: Gr 4 students with reading disability Varied lesson components depending on current skills 23 Contribution 13: What we understand about how typically developing readers learn to read also appears to hold for students with low incidence disabilities, including children with mild and moderate intellectual disabilities, and children who are deaf or hard of hearing.

Wise et al., 2010: Relations among reading skills are similar Browder et al., 2008: Takes more time, but comprehensive instruction is more effective than sight word approaches alone. Allor et al., 2010: Takes 3 years to achieve end-of-Gr1 outcomes Alberto et al., 2007, 2010: Comprehensive lessons for students with moderate/ severe ID Lederberg & colleagues (2008): Over 70% of students who are DHH may benefit from phonological and phonics-based reading approaches 24 And Since the Synthesis Was Published Response to Intervention Models Vocabulary Interventions in Middle Schools Technology 25 Response to Intervention (RtI) Models Does Beginning in K Matter (OConnor et al., 2014) Access to RtI in K or Gr 1 improve Gr 2 outcomes over typical practice RtI in K > RtI in Gr1 at the end of 1st grade Students who are English Language Learners (OConnor et al., 2014) Effects of K intervention lasted through 2nd grade for ELL Eliminated over- and under-identification of ELLs by 4th grade Long-term Outcomes with K-4 access to RtI (OConnor et al., 2013) Higher reading scores for students at risk

No statistical difference in percent of SpEd Those identified for SpEd had more severe deficits 26 Improving Vocabulary In Primary Grades: Improving teachers language-focused comprehension instruction and support also improved their overall classroom quality ratings (Justice et al., in press) Students in K-2 can learn morphology, but it

doesnt impact overall reading development (Apel & Diehm, 2013-14) 27 Vocabulary in Middle Schools Teachers use of sophisticated vocabulary is linked to vocabulary growth of students in their classes (Games & Leseaux, 2012; Silverman et al., 2013) Large-scale implementation by teachers of vocabulary programs yields positive and lasting effects (Lawrence, Snow et al., 2012; Lesaux & Kieffer, in press) WHO benefits differs:

Word Generation benefits native English speakers more than ELLs; students not proficient in English showed no effects ALIAS benefited ELL > EO 28 Students with Reading Disabilities in Middle Schools Direct reading intervention with 6th graders (Roberts, Fletcher, Vaughn et al., 2013) One year of small-group intervention improved students ability to compensate for poor verbal skills.

3 years improved reading comprehension and school behavior Direct intervention using U.S. History content (OConnor, Beach, Sanchez et al., in press) Improved word reading and vocabulary; generalized to history knowledge and reading comprehension Students who were ELL benefitted similarly in content, but needed more focus on academic language 29 Teacher-delivered Middle School Instruction

Teachers learned to improve explicit teaching of comprehension in U.S. History and Language Arts (Wanzek, Vaughn et al., 2013; Simmons et al., in press) Experimental classes > control classes In Language Arts, higher-performing students benefitted most In History, students with disabilities also performed better than SpEd in controls 30 Web-based Reading Tutors Teaching text structure in Gr 5-7 (Meyer, Wijekumar et al., 20102011)

Most effective innovation = elaborated feedback Lowest-skilled readers also benefit from explicit feedback on their errors Varied degree of individualization in feedback The more individualized, the better students learning and comprehension Individualized feedback also improved middle school students attitudes! 31 Professional Development How do we bring research-based instructional

practices to the classroom? 2 Contributions 32 Contribution 14 Contribution 14: We can improve many teachers delivery of complex, evidence-based instruction and interventions through developing their specialized knowledge and supporting consistent long-term implementation of evidence-based instructional practices. 33 Contribution 15 Contribution 15: Combining multiple professional development strategies, including coaching, linking student assessment data to instruction, using technology, and participating in communities of practice, can support teachers learning and implementation of research-based reading instruction. E.g., Carlisle et al., 2011 compared different combinations of PD. The greatest improvement in teacher practice was observed when teachers received workshops, learning how to assess students, and the support of a

literacy coach 34 And Since the Synthesis Was Published New technologies for teachers PD for CCSS 35 Implications

Where do we go from here? 36 Implications The first eight years of rigorous research funded by IES extended our knowledge about how to help students who have or are at risk for reading disabilities. The fifteen specific contributions that we identified through the published articles we reviewed reveal that IES-funded research has contributed in important ways to understanding how best to support students with or at risk for reading disabilities.

During its relatively short history, IES has required rigorous standards regarding how scientific information is obtained, particularly through the use of randomized controlled field trials in schools. Through IES, research findings now inform decision-making in education in ways that were simply not considered prior to its inception and we have reason to believe that IES funded research will continue to contribute meaningful and important research findings to the professional and research fields that support the successful education of children. 37 Next Steps from IES IES is in the process of identifying new areas

to synthesize IES-funded research. Currently reviewing work in social/behavioral contexts to support academic learning and mathematics. 38

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Fa b l e A s E x

    Fa b l e A s E x

    A Modern Fable "The Frog Who Isn't Talking to You" Elaborate, And Refute. mostly, though, it serves to underscore for us how rhetoric is largely about telling stories, and in particular, stories that, like this Icarus fable, tell a story...
  • An Analytic Disk Model - Inferences and Logical Structure

    An Analytic Disk Model - Inferences and Logical Structure

    The point is NOT that most disks in binaries are significantly massive -- just that SOME very interesting ones may be, and that issue needs investigation This contribution follows a sequence of papers on self gravitating analytic disk models, the...
  • Requirements Analysis and Specification

    Requirements Analysis and Specification

    Requirements Analysis and Specification Based on presentations by G. Mussbacher, G.V Bochmann, N. Niu, with material from: Wiegers: Software Requirements, Amyot 2008-2009, Somé 2008
  • Introductions - JIST Career Solutions

    Introductions - JIST Career Solutions

    Title: Introductions Author: hstith Last modified by: Jennifer Gehlhar Created Date: 8/10/2005 7:43:42 PM Document presentation format: On-screen Show (4:3)


    Bonds. When companies/government need money, they sell bonds to individuals. When an individual buys a bond, the individual becomes the lender. Government bonds have lower interest rates.


    CHALLENGING ISSUES IN INFECTIVE ENDOCARDITIS "Background" Despite improvement in health care and advancement in diagnostic technology and therapy; the incidence of infective endocarditis has not decreased over the past decades. Progressive evolution in risk factors: - i.e. i.v. drug use...
  • Le potentiel économique de la Côte d'ivoire

    Le potentiel économique de la Côte d'ivoire

    L'accueil favorable fait à La Chambre de Commerce et d'Industrie Libanaise de Côte d'Ivoire par les autorités ivoiriennes, et par tous les partenaires du secteur privé, traduit La volonté manifeste d'établir un partenariat structuré et efficace entre les principaux acteurs...
  • Windows 10 - Yola

    Windows 10 - Yola

    Free Windows 10. How to get Windows 10. System Scan for minimum hardware. Option to delay the installation . If you are currently running a legal version of Windows 7, 8 or 8.1 and have setup your system to receive...