# EML4550 - Engineering Design Methods Engineering-Economics Introduction Economic

EML4550 - Engineering Design Methods Engineering-Economics Introduction Economic Decision Rules Hyman: Chapter 8 EML4550 2007 1 Overview Engineering economics: The application of economic principles to engineering problems. Decision making of engineering design must balance trade-offs among cost (economic feasibility) and performance (technical accomplishments) in the most economical manner. A sound economical analysis should involve structured process and mathematical modeling techniques in order to meet design needs. EML4550 -- 2007 Economic Decision Criteria (from the simplest to the comprehensive) Simple criteria 1. Lowest initial cost (minimize capital cost) 2. Lowest overall life-cycle cost (no time value of money, regardless of when these costs occur) 3. Average annual rate of return (investment decision) 4. Payback period

Time value of money? Present Value Analysis Present value Annualized cost Unequal lifetimes analysis o o Common multiple of lifetimes Annualized cost of ownership and operation EML4550 -- 2007 Example: Ajax vs. Blaylock motors (Hyman Sec. 8.2) Need to decide between two brands/types of motors Ajax will cost \$30k and require \$1k/yr to maintain (high quality) Blaylock will cost \$20k and require \$2k/yr to maintain (lower quality) Furthermore, Blaylock requires an additional \$3k to rebuild after 3 years and has no resale value after 5 years, Ajax can be re-sold after 5 years for \$4k (salvage value) Ajax being a better motor, will decrease wear and tear on other systems, so factory will accrue \$500/yr in savings on other systems (gain in productivity) Ajax uses \$3k/yr in electricity, Blaylock uses \$3.5/yr in electricity Electricity rates increase by 5% each year (inflation) Ajax or Blaylock, which one should I buy? EML4550 -- 2007 Example: Ajax vs. Blaylock motors

(Hyman Sec. 8.2) ETU Ajax Blaylock Initial Cost 30 20 Rebuild at end of year 3 -- 3 Salvage value -4 -- 5 10 - 2.5 --

Year 1 3 3.5 Year 2 3.15 3.65 Year 3 3.31 3.86 Year 4 3.47 4.05 Year 5 3.65 4.25 45.08 52.34 Maintenance (5 years)

Productivity benefit (5 yrs) Electricity (O&M): Totals (No time value): EML4550 -- 2007 Criterion 1: Lowest capital cost Buy Blaylock (20 < 30) Cash-starved, no financing Unsophisticated buyer Ajax Blaylock Initial Cost 30 20 Rebuild at end of year 3 -- 3 Salvage value -4 -- Maintenance (5 years) 5

10 - 2.5 -- Year 1 3 3.5 Year 2 3.15 3.65 Year 3 3.31 3.86 Year 4 3.47 4.05 Year 5 3.65

4.25 45.08 52.34 Productivity benefit (5 yrs) Electricity (O&M): EML4550 -- 2007 Totals (No time value): Criterion 2: Lowest life-cycle cost No time value of money (simple addition of life-cycle costs) Choose Ajax (45.08 < 52.34) Slightly more sophisticated buyer Understanding of total cash flow Lacks understanding of Net Present Value (NPV) Ajax Blaylock Initial Cost 30 20 Rebuild at end of year 3 -- 3

Salvage value -4 -- Maintenance (5 years) 5 10 - 2.5 -- Year 1 3 3.5 Year 2 3.15 3.65 Year 3 3.31 3.86 Year 4

3.47 4.05 Year 5 3.65 4.25 45.08 52.34 Productivity benefit (5 yrs) Electricity (O&M): EML4550 -- 2007 Totals (No time value): Criterion 3: Average annual rate of return Assume the lowest cost option is the base case Calculate the % return on investment of paying extra money to buy the better equipment Is the % return high enough? EML4550 -- 2007 Criterion 3: Average annual rate of return Incremental investment = Initial cost (expensive) - Initial cost (cheap) = 30 - 20 = \$10k Downstream benefits of Ajax motor:

Avoidance of rebuilding Income from salvage Savings on maintenance Increased in productivity revenue Savings in electricity: Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 +3 +4 (10-5)=+5 +2.5 (3.5-3)=+0.5 (3.65-3.15)=+0.5 (3.86-3.31)=+0.55 (4.05-3.47)=+0.58 (4.25-3.65)=+0.6 Sum of all benefits: \$17.23k EML4550 -- 2007 Criterion 3: Average annual rate of return

Total benefits from extra investment (no time value of money): \$17.26k Average annual benefit over five years = 17.23k/5 = \$3.45k Average annual rate of return = 3.45/10 = 34.5% (assume \$10k initial investment by choosing the more expensive Ajax motor) Is this attractive? Compare with corporate hurdle rate (a rate of return above which an investment makes sense and below which it does not. Also called required rate of return or profit margin.) Can the additional expenses be invested in other options to achieve higher profit margin (>34.5%)? Need benchmark data for comparison. EML4550 -- 2007 Criterion 4: Payback period Extra investment of \$10k, when do I get it back? Benefits: Maintenance + Productivity + Electricity Year 1: 1 + 0.5 + 0.5 = 2 Years 1+2: 2 + 1 + 0.5 + 0.53 = 4.03 Years 1+2+3: 4.03 + 1 + 0.5 + 0.55 +3 (rebuild cost) = 9.05 Years 1+2+3+4: 9.05 + 1 + 0.5 + 0.58 = 11.13 Payback period ~ 3.5 years Attractive? Not attractive? Soon enough? A benchmark is needed to justify the economical value. EML4550 -- 2007

## Recently Viewed Presentations

• "To eliminate the volume and toxicity of waste and recover resources" Refuse. Reduce. Reuse. Recycle. Rot. The infamous mason jar. Just by existing we are going to create waste - the goal of zero waste is not to leave absolutely...
• แคมเปญ ผ่านช่องทางเช่น LINE Business CRM, Direct Marketing, Chatbot, Internet of Things, Ad Optimization . จะกลายมาเป็น . DATA . ... Picture Promise Prove Push (PPPP) Picture
• raman-active modes DIAMOND is a 3-D crystal, where the carbon atoms are bonded to 4 neighbors with four-fold sp3 bonding. This crystalline sp3 bonding is what gives diamond its extremely hard properties.
• Test tasks Recognition Perceptual Identification Explicit vs. Implicit Memory Jacoby (1983): Generation Effect Opposite pattern of results with implicit task Roediger & Weldon, (1987) Study tasks Lists of pictures and words Test tasks Free recall of pictures and words Word...
• PESSCL. £500 million hand out in 2002. Again in 2004. 85% participating in at least 2 hrs PE and School Sport a week by 2008. Sporting Future for All. 2000, Labour emphasis. 5 visions: sport in education (SSP's etc), sport...
• Little Turtle . Blue Jacket. Treaty of Fort Harmar ... never did I see, As happened on the plains, near the River St. Marie.3. Our militia were attacked, just as the day did break, And soon were overpowered, and forced...
• TOK cannot be used as a subject area. EE Subject Areas, Continued. ... Sample Research Questions ... and lend itself to systematic investigation. Essays that focus on the last 10 years are not acceptable. Sample Research Questions "Causes of the...
• Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has." -- Margaret Mead Planning for the Future: Visioning, Current Opportunities and Barriers Planning for the Future: Visioning Slide 5 Slide 6 If we Nurture our Dreams, they will take Root in...