Investigating pedagogy in research methods Melanie Nind Newcastle

Investigating pedagogy in research methods Melanie Nind Newcastle

Investigating pedagogy in research methods Melanie Nind Newcastle University Seminar, 2nd April 2015 [email protected] 1. The landscape of research methods pedagogy 2. Findings to date 3. Developing pedagogical culture and dialogue around research methods 2

The landscape of research methods pedagogy UK context ESRC concern with social science research capacity and global competitiveness Advent of ESRC Doctoral Training Centres Shift from apprenticeship/ supervision only to taught courses/formal training 4 Wider European Context Salzburg Principles fostering adoption of more

structured forms of doctoral training Conception of doctoral learners as early stage researchers undergoing preparation for the job market Advocated by European University Associations (EUA) Council for Doctoral Education (Kottmann 2011) 5 The landscape according to the literature Wagner et al. (2011: 85): systematic review of lit 19972007 concluded: There remains little evidence of a pedagogic culture for methods teaching (if the indicator is

systematic debate through the literature or dialogue across disciplinary or methodological contexts, or if the indicator is a substantial research base substantial body of literature addressing the how to of research methods does not adequately inform the teaching of methods (Wagner et al, 2011: 75) 6 Earley (2013): more extensive synthesis of literature found mostly insights from particular instructors, courses, or institutions contributing little on how students actually learn research methods; teachers needing to rely on a network of peers, scattered research literature, and

much trial-and-error for developing their practice (p.2) Kilburn, Nind & Wiles (2014): thematic review of 24 papers on how teachers facilitate methods learning found emerging pedagogical dialogue regarding teaching for active, experiential, and reflexive forms of learning 7 Two discourses One around doctoral education (with some pedagogic dialogue) One around training and

capacity building (with a pedagogic void) 8 Research questions How do social science researchers learn about social research methods? How do teachers/trainers of research methods develop and use their methods-based and pedagogical knowledge for developing the methodological

learning of others? 9 Findings to date 15 month study including: semi-structured interviews with specialists (n8) 3 focus groups with methods teachers (n14) online discussion forum with methods learners (n18) 4 video-stimulated focus groups with teachers & learners (n8+25) thematic, iterative analysis of combined dataset

11 Themes in the data (i) challenges re teaching and learning advanced or innovative methods (ii) teaching approaches used, valued or regarded as problematic (iii) pedagogical content knowledge (iv) innovation in methods for research / methods of teaching & learning (v) qualities of methods teachers/trainers & learners 12

Challenges Learner gaps/poor preparation Learner/context matches & mismatches Fearful learners, complex material Timing, sequencing, pace There are deficits or big gaps in the kind of [methodological] skills Learner diversity set that particularly Social Science

For any kind of learning to be maximally beneficial, it has to occur at a point when you are likely to put it into practice. undergraduates emerge from higher education with. When I started my fieldwork it was a 'learn as you go' experience. Maybe that's the nature of it. 13

Approaches Motivating, guiding Maximizing dialogue/interaction Active, reflective, deep Embedded Maximizing use of materials (data) critical appreciation,

Self as resource its very much based stimulating a sort of statistical imagination or thinking on them then working through practice by that point we kind of knew each other well enough that it was really helpful doing this group work

14 PCK regarding material, sequence, strategies what is problematic what to include & what to leave out mix of input & inter/action balance of conceptual & operational, imagination

& technique I think youre right, its I rail against the separation of [advanced training] from the research problem about holding my nerve as an organiser, and allowing there to be big blank space to sit there. theres a sequence, so the order in which I

show things in the software is not random 15 What emerges is picture of Pedagogical knowledge with references to experience and reflection as sources Some trial and error and gradual shaping of pedagogical approach (praxis) Use of evaluation data and feedback in the moment Teachers as learners and learners as teachers Some specialist language at teachers disposal, yet little reference to any pedagogical literature

16 But also apparent is Considerable pedagogical reflection when prompted Teachers and learners making good use of dialogic spaces for pedagogic discussion (created via different perspectives in tension) Not as simple as research methods instructors teach[ing] the way they were taught (Strayhorn 2009: 120) 17 Developing pedagogical culture and

dialogue around research methods Taken forward to the next study Enhancing methodological skills requires finely tuned learning experiences not just more TCB Pedagogical research can help develop a pedagogical culture for teaching research methods Tacit knowledge can be made explicit through dialogic processes (making it more amenable to development) Despite some oversimplified language of outputs, there is also scope for alternative rich storying (Todd, 2007: 84) of what is going on in methods teaching & learning for the individuals involved.

19 New research 2015-2017 Intended to create pedagogic dialogical spaces i.e. to open and sustain a dialogue between teachers of research methods, those concerned with providing advanced methods training to researchers, methodology researchers and learners of research methods. 20 Research design 2105-2017 Building from

earlier national expert panel International expert panel Case studies Method-ological & pedagogical innovation Building

from earlier VSRR work VSR dialogue Learner journeys Exploring how learners use materials & opportunities 21

Would you like to be involved? Would you like to take part in video-stimulated dialogue? Could you keep a diary of your research methods learning journey over 30 months? Are you doing something innovative with research methods or the teaching and learning of them? If so, make contact [email protected]

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • The Sun - Cabrillo College

    The Sun - Cabrillo College

    Ch 14 Key Points - The Sun. Know the layers of the sun. Magnetic fields cause splitting of spectral lines, allows us to measure them in the Universe - Zeeman Effect. Sun: balance of nuclear powered pressure and inward gravity.
  • Theory of Change: A Blueprint for Evaluation Presentation

    Theory of Change: A Blueprint for Evaluation Presentation

    What we do as a part of the programme- deliver, teach, offer loans, etc. What are the resources used -funds, staff, equipment, curriculum, all materials. Tangible products or services produced as a result of the activities - usually can be...
  • WintellectNOW


    Displaying Form Validation InformationOverview. In previous videos of this series, Reactive Forms, Template Forms, Validators, Custom Validators and such have been explored, explained and demonstrated
  • Self Introduction in Japanese

    Self Introduction in Japanese

    Self Introduction in Japanese 1 Hajimemashite. 2 Watashi no namae wa desu. 3 Watashi wa sai desu. 4 Watashi wa nensei desu. 5 Watashi wa kara desu. 6 Douzo yoroshiku.
  • The Consultative Project Manager

    The Consultative Project Manager

    Consultative PM Competency Model. Project Management Fundamentals. Technical Acumen. Competency: Description; Business Acumen. Able to understand the industry and business model of the company and understand linkages between project goals and company-specific business context.
  • Applied Climatology and the Role of NOAAs Regional

    Applied Climatology and the Role of NOAAs Regional

    Office 1991-97 National Weather Service 1997 National Climatic Data Center 2006 Nationally Competed (transfer of SERCC) What are RCCs? Regional hubs for user-centric climate services, interdisciplinary climate research, applications and education that provide a regional focus to addressing societal needs.
  • Comenius Regio Partnerships

    Comenius Regio Partnerships

    Comenius Regio Partnerships 'A powerful collaborative force through which to tackle a diverse range of issues with social as well as educational implications'
  • Ag Bank Sim

    Ag Bank Sim

    Ag Bank Sim Setting. Provide a learning experience in making bank decisions. Increase understanding of the interactions among decisions. Generate discussion regarding impact of decisions. Objectives. Ag is a principal industry, particularly. Cow-calf. Stocker cattle .